Serafina is really into Earthborn Hollistic canned, particularly the fish flavors. She eats quite a bit of Weruva and Tiki Cat also, and she also enjoys Orijen dry food. Neytiri will eat just about anything (thankfully! Hooray for having an easy cat!), so she generally eats what Serafina is eating (in a separate bowl of course).
Gaga is my problem eater. For months she was nibbling at this and that and showing no enthusiasm for anything except Blue Wilderness dry, duck flavor (must be duck flavor). But I discovered about a month ago that she will wolf down Rad Cat raw food (chicken or turkey). And the really odd thing about this is that once she's wolfed down her generous sized portion of that, she will THEN be interested in whatever Serafina and Neytiri are eating. Hmmm.
It's like it stimulates her appetite and then she's like "oh yea, that other stuff might not be bad either...". Anyway, I'd love to rid myself and my cats of the Blue Buffalo food after the latest debacle, but it really is the only dry food that Gaga will eat. So only she gets it. The other two get the much better Orijen.