Alright thank you so much everyone. Sorry I know I said I would update on Friday but its been a busy week/weekend. We have family from both sides in town so my time alone has been near to none. Thanks for all the reply and suggestions. If I miss anything just let me know and I will answer sometime today :)
So one of the questions was his food. Yes the vet did recommend the change in food to see if he had a sensitive stomach and so far so good. Though I am not certain on the brand. Has anyone ever heard of Natural Balance? The duck and pea kind? So far so good on the food change, he actually takes the food as treats he really likes it.
So now as for the last time he was peeing, to be honest I'm not entirely sure how it was resolved. We just added extra litter boxes, since I had only two, and the third helped. I also closed off the second bedroom on which he was peeing. Cleaned everything well and poof he just stopped.
Also, as for the mention of getting rid of Finnegan, I would have to be absolutely desperate to do that, I love him so much, and am so attached, the thought of getting rid of him just breaks my heart. I did talk to my boyfriend about it and he said he was just joking about the deadline, but I guess I take things a little to seriously when I'm stressed out. (that was pretty mean) Also yes, it has been the same boyfriend since I had Finn we got him a little over a year ago and we have all lived together the entire time. So no changes to stress him out there. ( but he does love new people, as in chases them down the streets when I take him out, and loves company so I dont think that would have done it for him.)
Now what does the vet think? And what have we done so far? So we had a urine analysis test done. The vet says its near perfect, and after a lot of talking and explaining our situation, she also seems to think it is behavioral. We had physical exam and spent almost 45 minutes with the vet and tech. I brought my little black book with all the days and times and places Finn's peed, what we did surrounding those times. So we have come up with a plan. The bedroom is always closed off unless we are sleeping in the bed. I got rid of the old couch since it smelled horrible and bought a futon put a waterproof cover on it and am just using 5 dollar sheets so anytime he pees we throw it out, so there is no smell left at all. ( no peeing since thursday morning so far
) Also anytime we leave the house he gets locked up in the bathroom, with toys and food and litter, a comfy bed and his own personal lamp. We are to make it a good experience for him so of course treats are involved. (but also loves his new food so I just give him that instead half of the time. ) There is also a Feliway diffusee in the bathroom. He is praised and welcomed out when we get home. I am happy he and Aleya aren't that close and they don't seem to mind the separation. If we are only leaving for an hour or so sometimes I lock Aleya with him so they can spend some quality time together. Now if he starts to pee anywhere in the bathroom or on the couch again when we are home, we are going to schedule an xray to see if it is stones, or kidney related (but she doesn't think so since there is usually signs of kidney issues in the urin test.) The vet also thinks it may be anxiety so we will keep a close eye on him for that also.
Side note, I have also taken the hoods off my litter trays and he seems to like that better since he likes standing on the sides of the boxes when he pees. He still does try and cover the litter and scratches the wall so the litter behind the couch is soon going to be a big Tupperware container twice the size. Found some on sale but are all out, shipment should be in next week. I did change their litter while this whole thing was in full swing since I found our old litter smelled bad, and bought some arm and hammer litter and I find it smells much nicer and doesn't stick to their paws so much.
One other thing we found was he always crys to go outside he loves outside so much its seems to be an addiction. So I make sure to make time at least 30 minutes during the day or evening to bring him outside, and he seems to be a little bit happier, I have been doing good with the two of them listening so I don't need to wait for my boyfriend to take one and I the other. Aleya seems to be enjoying this time more and more, they actually started to run and chase me outside so its pretty fun.
All in all I think I covered all your questions and if I missed any feel free to let me know. Also any other suggestions I am open to them.
Thank you so so much everyone! I really appreciate the support you guys have shown and your tips are and stories are great to hear.
Stephanie, Aleya and Finnegan